Thomas Hobbes wrote that, without the protection of a monarch, "the life of man [is] solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short." This is the phrase with which Hobbes is most associated, and it is often considered a kind of statist apology: the justification for the state is that, without it, we are torn apart in an alienating "civil war." In other words, the state of nature is supposed to be a violence that divides, and the state proper is a peace that multiplies.
The first response to Hobbes is not, however, to contest his vision of the state of nature, trying to find, say, instances where nature is not as violent as he suggests. This might be the response of an anarchistic thinker, seeking a kind of purity in nature verifiable in fact. (This response may follow as a secondary response, but after the first response it will seem less necessary.) Instead, we need only look at what Hobbes has written to find his error.
By taking a slight liberty in interpretation, understanding society and language as fundamentally connected, Hobbes' phrase can be re-written: man without discourse is violent. This interpretation is possible because language is useless to the "solitary" individual, and meaning only arises when another acknowledges it; simply, language is social.
Moreover, this statement, "man without discourse is violent," is not any more offensive or objectionable than the first statement. We can easily imagine that language is a way to mediate violence. In fact, this is how we commonly negotiate conflict; it is the idea behind calls to "talk it out," or to engage in "peace talks."
This rephrasing of Hobbes now reveals, however, that the statement is actually impossible, and hence says nothing at all, because "man" is never without discourse.
According to certain linguistic thinking, it is impossible to suppose an original language (ie. that language which follows directly from natural experience). This is the methodological conflict between (1) seeking to follow the thread of language back through increasingly basic forms (etymology, diachronism) until words correspond directly with objects (which will, in my view, never happen) and (2) assuming that the first language was already a full, self-referential language (synchronism) when it appeared on the scene (in effect, that there is no first language).
The second option is the only viable one because words only make sense in relation to other words, and hence in order for them to emerge they have to emerge all at once. The first option is also wrong because the difference between nature and language, which the idea of an original language presumes to be entirely bridgeable, is in fact impossible to bridge. If there ever was a moment where an original human society passed from wordless nature into discourse, it is completely lost without even a trace to us because we would immediately encounter epistemological barriers resulting from our own immanence in language; we would have no idea what the wordless person was; we would have trouble recognizing anything of ourselves in them without the kind of imaginative leap which is more reflection than knowing.
Recalling, then, that language is social, the scene described above is also a social scene. The language that emerges all at once has to emerge in a society that exists all at once. Otherwise, there would be no point in ever developing a language. In purely behaviourist terms, there would be no relationship of stimulus-response to encourage continuing the behaviour of language; someone would utter a sound and it would fall on either the deaf ears of another being without language or the dead ears of nature, but there would be no reason to continue making that sound. Thus, the language that is already a language is the product of a society that is already a society: the process of becoming either is impossible.
The error of Hobbes is therefore that he builds his state in opposition to something that cannot exist. The phrase, "the life of man [is] solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short," is therefore ideological in Slavoj Zizek's sense of a fantasy that makes us overlook some fundamental inconsistency in society. "The life of Man" never was "solitary," although it may have been "Nasty, brutish, and short." This, however, occurred under the king anyway, and Hobbes does not deny this fact:
"But, though there had never been any time wherein particular men were in a condition of war one against another, yet in all times kings and persons of sovereign authority, because of their independency, are in continual jealousies and in the state and posture of gladiators, having their weapons pointing, and their eyes fixed on one another, that is, their forts, garrisons, and guns, upon the frontiers of their kingdoms, and continual spies upon their neighbours: which is a posture of war. But because they uphold thereby the industry of their subjects, there does not follow from it that misery which accompanies the liberty of particular men."The fault therefore lies with the sovereign if "the industry of their subjects" is not upheld, certainly, but the thing that the sovereign is supposed to guarantee for their subjects is not our original notion of "a peace that multiplies." This is something that must emerge out of language and the social itself. The sovereign therefore appears illegitimate; it owes us everything and we owe it nothing.
When Woody Guthrie writes, "I ain't got no home in this world anymore," he is still at home in language. That, at least, was not yet taken from him (https://theconversation.com/woody-guthrie-old-man-trump-and-a-real-estate-empires-racist-foundations-53026).
If there are any objections that my "slight liberty in interpretation" was not slight at all, that this is not what Hobbes meant, and that Hobbes really meant the raw existence of single individuals without language, recall that the idea of an individual enacts the same contradiction as the idea of original language. There is no individual that is not born of two parents. Moreover, the association of Hobbes' phrase with language is in the full original: "no account of time, no arts, no letters, no society, and, which is worst of all, continual fear and danger of violent death, and the life of man solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short [my italics]."
Source: Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan, Book One, Chapter XIII, http://www.bartleby.com/34/5/13.html.
No comments:
Post a Comment